When Ronald Reagan set out in 1981 to nominate the first female justice, Sixth Circuit judge Cornelia Kennedy was the most obvious candidate.
Of the eleven women then sitting on the federal courts of appeals, Kennedy was the only one with a clearly conservative record. When liberal groups opposed her elevation from the district court to the Sixth Circuit, conservative Republican senator Orrin Hatch hailed her on the Senate floor as “probably the most exceptional woman judge in the country.”
Yet Kennedy lost out to a virtual unknown, Sandra Day O’Connor. Why that happened (as best I can reconstruct things) offers lessons about the pressures and incentives that shape a president’s selection of a Supreme Court nominee.
***



